top of page

Pleasers vs. Challengers in Executive Leadership

At the pinnacle of any organization, the role of a leader transcends merely making decisions; it involves navigating through challenges, unlocking opportunities for others, and eventually becoming part of the collective success. The reality is that, as a top executive, you seldom possess the luxury of influencing the final outcome. It's a complex dance where not only the market or the business dictates what's right or wrong, but also your team - a team that relentlessly and insatiably demands your attention.

Your team, meticulously selected for their execution prowess, serves as the driving force once a decision is made. However, in the interim, they become the architects of resistance, pushing you, sometimes with formidable strength, to uncover the optimal solution in the best interest of the business. Their role is not confined to execution excellence alone; they were chosen because they bring a unique perspective to the table. They are not just skilled individuals; they are experts, and as their leader, you bear the obligation to listen to their insights. After all, why assemble a team of experts if not to leverage their collective wisdom?

Falcon 9 Challenger

Pleasers vs Challengers, and Organizational Success

Consider this: Are you surrounded by individuals who aim to please, or have you built a team of Challengers? The distinction is pivotal. A team of Pleasers may nod in agreement, accepting the status quo without question. On the other hand, true leaders, the Challengers, possess an unwavering energy to make their voices resonate. They are unafraid to challenge, to question, and to propel the organization forward.

In the corridors of executive leadership, complacency is the enemy. So, take a moment to introspect: Is your immediate team challenging you enough? Have they transcended the comfort of agreement and embraced the discomfort of dissent? In this exploration, we delve into the crucial dynamics of leadership, urging you to evaluate if your team is not just executing but challenging - a distinction that could define the trajectory of your organization's success.

Recognizing and Managing Pleaser Dynamics in Your Team

Let's analyze how to identify Pleasers and manage them:

(1) Silent Consensus Seekers

Indicator: Team members who consistently seek consensus without expressing dissenting opinions during discussions.

Strategy: Encourage open dialogue and explicitly ask for diverse opinions. Create a culture that values constructive criticism and rewards alternative viewpoints.

(2) Avoidance of Conflict

Indicator: Individuals who tend to avoid conflicts or disagreements, preferring to maintain harmony within the team.

Strategy: Introduce scenarios that require critical decision-making and observe how team members handle disagreements. Those who consistently avoid conflict may be Pleasers.

(3) Reluctant Decision Makers

Indicator: Team members who hesitate to take the lead in decision-making, waiting for clear instructions from leadership.

Strategy: Assign responsibilities that demand autonomy and decision-making. Observe how individuals respond to ambiguity and their ability to take decisive action.

(4) Overemphasis on Agreement

Indicator: Constant agreement without presenting counterarguments or exploring alternative solutions.

Strategy: Encourage devil's advocate roles during discussions. Evaluate how team members respond when their ideas are challenged or when they need to challenge others.

(5) Overly Dependence on Approval

Indicator: Individuals who consistently seek approval before making decisions or taking action.

Strategy: Foster an environment that values initiative and independent decision-making. Assess how team members handle situations where immediate approval may not be feasible.

Strategies to Identify and Empower Challenger Dynamics

Let's analyze how to identify Challengers and manage them:

(1) Proactive Problem Solvers

Indicator: Team members who actively identify problems, propose solutions, and take initiative without waiting for instructions.

Strategy: Assign projects that require creative problem-solving. Observe how individuals approach challenges and their ability to present innovative solutions.

(2) Constructive Disagreement

Indicator: Individuals who respectfully voice dissenting opinions, challenging the status quo during discussions.

Strategy: Encourage debates and discussions. Recognize and reward those who present well-reasoned counterarguments, fostering an environment where diverse opinions are valued.

(3) Initiators of Change

Indicator: Team members who proactively suggest changes or improvements to existing processes.

Strategy: Create avenues for feedback and improvement suggestions. Identify those who consistently contribute ideas to enhance efficiency and effectiveness.

(4) Risk-Takers

Indicator: Individuals who demonstrate a willingness to take calculated risks rather than always opting for the safest route.

Strategy: Assign tasks that involve an element of risk or uncertainty. Assess how team members approach challenges and whether they display a willingness to venture into uncharted territory.

(5) Ownership of Decisions

Indicator: Team members who take ownership of decisions, both successes, and failures, rather than deflecting responsibility.

Strategy: Provide opportunities for autonomy and decision-making. Observe how individuals handle accountability and learn from experiences, regardless of the outcome.

Transforming Teams from Pleasers to Challengers

Jump Challenge

Consider the dynamics at play within your immediate team. Are they architects of resistance, pushing you to unveil optimal solutions, or have they succumbed to the comfort of agreement? The discomfort of dissent, embraced by true leaders, fuels progress and propels organizations beyond the mundane.

As you delve into the art of managing Pleaser dynamics, remember: silence is not always agreement, and consensus-seeking may camouflage dissent. Nurture a culture that values diverse opinions and rewards constructive criticism. Challenge the tendency to avoid conflict, for within those disagreements often lie the seeds of innovation.

Pleasers Meeting

On the flip side, empowering Challenger dynamics involves recognizing the proactive problem solvers, the voices of constructive disagreement, the initiators of change, the risk-takers, and those who claim ownership of decisions. These individuals are not just team members; they are the catalysts of transformation.

"Every champion was once a challenger." - Luke Campbell

So, as you contemplate the intricacies of leadership, ask yourself: Is your team a melting pot of complacency, or have you ignited the flames of innovation? The journey from Pleasers to Challengers is not just a shift in mindset; it's a transformational odyssey that defines the trajectory of success.

The bonus question remains: After each interaction, each decision, and each interview, do you find yourself wondering, "Will this individual challenge us to be better?" It's not just a question; it's a reflection of your commitment to excellence and the catalyst for transformative leadership.

326 views0 comments


Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page